What happened when the script was flipped
It was billed as an event to kick off a renewed conversation about how Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) communities can work better together to push forward race equality and survive in this age of austerity.

It was billed as an event to kick off a renewed conversation about how Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) communities can work better together to push forward race equality and survive in this age of austerity.

And, for many of the 120 delegates who packed into the Bernie Grant Arts Centre last week, the Alternative Perspectives conference succeeded in stimulating a much-needed debate at the right time.
Conference organisers Voice4Change England wanted the event to change the narrative, or ‘flip the script’, from justified concern over the absence of ‘race’ on the political agenda towards discussing practical ideas about what BME voluntary sector organisations can do about it.
You can view the full conference programme here, and read the conference blog here.
The free all-day conference saw the launch of a discussion pamphlet which argued that anti-racist activists needed to switch out of auto-pilot because the old ways of campaigning were proving less effective over time.
The pamphlet, written by Dr Sanjiv Lingayah and commissioned by V4CE, was discussed at a session called ‘redefining race in the 21st century’. You can read the document here.
Delegates made full use of the #flipthescript Twitter hashtag and free Wifi. Shareefa Energy, who performed poetry at the event (see picture), tweeted: “Inspiring day and people at the Alternative Perspectives @V4CE conference.”
Alexandra Ankrah from the Tutu Foundation added: “Thanks 2 @V4CE 4 today’s powerful gathering & opportunity 2 talk.”
You can read the collected tweets from the conference here. Overall we had 65 tweets, 84 retweets and 34 favourites.
The conference opened with a performance by hip-hop poet Awate and a welcome from Sharon Grant, widow of the late Bernie Grant and inspiration behind the arts centre. The day was compered by Tony Smikle, a former senior policeman and now policing consultant.
Redefining Race
In the ‘redefining race’ panel Russell Profitt, chief executive of the Greenwich Inclusion Project, responded to Dr Lingayah’s paper by saying we must remember past struggles and “throwing the baby out with the bathwater”.
The panel, chaired by Neena Samota, V4CE’s chair of trustees, heard from Arwa Almari, from the West Yorkshire Racial Justice network, who said that “racism is on the move” and changing in nature but is no less dangerous or pernicious.
She cited the recent murder of Saudi Arabian student Nahid Almanea and drew a parallels with the stripping away of Britain’s equalities framework under the Governments’ ‘red tape challenge’ to show that BME people had less protection in a hostile climate.
Awate (left), who came to national prominence in May after taking on UKIP’s Sanya-Jeet Thandi on Channel 4 News shortly before Thandi quit the party, highlighted the role of the media in shaping attitudes and said that talking about ‘race’ remained uncomfortable for many.
The audience discussion that followed looked at new alternative strategies for raising the need to tackle racism in all its’ forms by stronger alliances, as well as looking at what ‘black’ means in order to embrace and engage with all who face race discrimination.
It was suggested that Britain is “at a crossroads”, but that BME communities must continue to strive for self-determination and against “global white supremacist ideology.”
Partnerships and Collaborations
The partnerships and collaborations session brought together Nero Ughwujabo from Croydon BME Forum, Angela Baugh from Sheffield BME Network, Vivienne Hayes from the Women’s Resource Centre, V4CE’s development officer Saqib Deshmukh and was chaired by Caroline Schwaller from the national infrastructure body NAVCA.
Discussions focussed on strategies for increasing funding income, how the community and voluntary sector can bridge the gap with the ‘grassroots’, and what opportunities existed for BME VCS to work in multiagency partnerships.
The session followed publication last year of V4CE’s report ‘Barriers to Collaboration and Partnerships Between BME and Mainstream Organisations in London’, which you can read here, that made 17 recommendations which mainstream and infrastructure organisations and funders could put in place.
Social enterprise
The conference featured four workshop seminars, which were all repeated during the day. One of them focussed on social enterprise and was led by John Mayford of Olmec which advises SMEs , and Nathalie Richards from the SME EduKit who is also a V4CE trustee.
Richards gave a breakdown of what a social enterprise and community interest company was, and talked about the trade-off between funding opportunities and autonomy.
Mayford gave some history and context to social enterprises and co-ops. Both said it was all about identifying the market and doing research.
It was important not to be dependent on one source of income, eg. a local authority contract. A number of individual funding sources were mentioned.
Representation in the media
This seminar featured panellists Eva Simpson, a former news executive at The Times, Juliette Foster, ex-Sky News anchor now at Arise TV, Akua Gyamfi from the British Blacklist, former CBBC Newsround presenter Nelufar Hedayat, and Mike Doherty from the Travellers Movement. The session was chaired by V4CE policy officer Lester Holloway, a presenter on Colourful Radio and former Editor of the New Nation newspaper.
Doherty gave some practical examples of what action had been taken to challenge unfair representation of Irish travellers in the media, including legal judicial reviews, ‘flashmob’ protests outside the Spectator magazine, complaints to the press regulator and working with campaign group Hacked Off to design better recourse against offensive stereotyping in the media.
Hedayat argued that aspiring BME journalists should not hold themselves back through fear of being discriminated against because that can become a self-fulfilling prophesy, but Foster said that it was common for BME people in the sector to face glass ceilings. Simpson spoke about her journey in the media and offered tips for getting a foot in the door.
Education
The education seminar was led by a team from Race on the Agenda and included panellists Pascale Vassie from National Resource Centre for Supplementary Education, Kristine Wellington from Hackney CVS, Shareefa Energy, Arzu Merali from the Islamic Human Rights Commission, and was chaired by writer Amrit Wilson and activist David Dalgleish.
Discussion included the regulation of supplementary schools which some suspect is cover for Prevent-style McCarthyite hunts to find ‘extremism’.
There was also concern about lack of funding for supplementary schools, and that Michael Gove’s free schools were not only exempt from the national curriculum but also were not complying with the Public Sector Equality Duty under the 2006 Equality Act. Some felt that free schools failed to engage with BME communities.
Policing
The policing seminar involved panellists Estelle Boulay from the Newham Monitoring Project, Taher Gulamhussein from the Islamic Human Rights Commission, Patrick Williams from Manchester Metropolitan University, Smikle, Awate, Shareefa Energy and was chaired by Deshmukh.
This looked at the racialization of gangs and the need for bespoke solutions tailored to each community, as well as the need to inform communities of their rights when unfairly confronted by officers and how we can better hold the police to account.
Smikle, who served 25 years in the force, said there was ‘oppression’ inside the service as well, against BME officers who spoke out. The establishment of the Black Police Association upset a lot of officers who accused it of ‘racism’ but the BPA had brought about some positive change.
Williams said that 20 percent of young people on the gangs database had never been convicted and that the label of gangs was to an extent a device to over-police black communities. Boulay agreed and said that tackling gangs had turned into ‘a business.’
The session also looked at the targeting of Muslim communities. Shareefa Energy recalled how, in Leicester, she was unknowingly a part of a group that got Prevent funding and was shocked when she discovered this.
Solutions included better police accountability, an issue that had been set back with the abolition of police authorities and their replacement with elected crime commissioners.
There was also a need to improve monitoring of policing with action to investigate disproportionality.
Lunch and networking
The conference included a delicious free Caribbean lunch provided by Blooming Scent caterers which also provided an opportunity for delegates to network.
V4CE would like to extend our thanks to the Bernie Grant Arts Centre, and are grateful for all the positive tweets and feedback received from the evaluation forms.
Next steps
V4CE are evaluating the feedback, including calls for new or stronger networks to exchange ideas and share best practice to capacity-build the BME voluntary and community sector and more effectively lobby decision-makers to put race equality on the agenda.
In the meantime V4CE will be developing its’ consultancy services, as advertised in the conference brochure, and will be keeping the delegates and all our stakeholders fully informed of all developments.
For more information visit our website: archive.voice4change-england.org , email us at info@voice4change-england.co.uk or call on (020) 7697 4242.
Check out our Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/VoiceforChangeEngland and Twitter @V4CE.
Conference blog: http://alternativeperspectives.org Conference programme http://www.scribd.com/doc/231581144/Alternative-Perspectives-Conference-Programme














By Lester Holloway
